For the price of 2, Erebor Hammersmith has quite good stats and impressive number of hit points. His ability is always welcomed mostly in scenarios full of nasty treacheries removing your attachments. He also work well with Forest Snare if you already used it. In combination with Dáin Ironfoot he becomes great cheap ally with very good stats and longevity. The artwork is fine. Verdict : 4/5.
Response: After you play Erebor Hammersmith, return the topmost attachment in any player's discard pile to his hand.
Core Set #59. Lore.
Erebor Hammersmith is pure gold even outside of one of seastan's broken decks. Two for one of anything is good and three hit points to boot. His discard mechanic is just icing on the cake. If you're running Dain this guy becomes two for a massive two, two, one, and three!