best fighting 1

goal:

find the best fightingdeck for multiplayer

"rules" (make other rules if you like, but these are those that fit my experiences for multiplayer for challenging szenarios)

start: points for save actions, half points for possible actions (e.g. needs #mail for sentinal)

first round effectivness:

point for defense with 5 or more
half a point for additional defense (5 or more) without sentinel
point for each additional sentinel with defense of 4 (or more)
point for doable attacks (first vanilla, others ranged or additional engaging or sideeffects) with str of 5 or more (reducing defense counts as + for attackstr) point for each average shadowcancelling

mid/lategame effectivness:

what power does it have 3 round:

a deck get a point for each sentinel with 6 or more
point for each average shadowcancelling
point for each doable attack (ranged, additional engage) with 7 or more, half for each with 5 or more
point if healing or damagecancel is possible
point for possible attacking in the staging

here are 2 examples

childs of elrond:

starting save: 0 starting possible:

(steward on elrohir (with aid of arwen), gondorian shield on elrohir 3 regular defenses (with his ability) 1 points
- blade on elladan, 2 attacks (with his ability) 1 points

midgame effectivness 3 round:

bow, courage, weapon and mark on elladan 2 attacks + ressources on him 2 thx to arwen) 4 points
valiant shield and elvenmail on elladan then up to 6 defenses with sentinel (thx to his ability 6 points
healing with contract 1 point
shadowcancel with arwen Hasty Stroke 1 point

overall 14

ranged beregond(s)

start save:

starting possible:

3 additional defenses with beregond sentinel or #feint (Behind Strong Walls or , Miruvor ), 1,5 points
2 ranged attacks (str 5) with horse on bard and bow on legolas, 1 point

start overall 5,5

midgame:

mid overall: 10, together 15,5